Sonic x Shadow Generations Switch Review: Sonic Team Reimagines a Modern Classic

Sonic x Shadow Generations Launches on Nintendo Switch: A Refined Return from Sonic Team and SEGA Sonic x Shadow Generations, developed by Sonic Team and published by SEGA, makes its highly anticipated arrival on the Nintendo Switch on October 25, 2024.

Building on the legacy of 2011's Sonic Generations, this reimagined release looks to balance nostalgic homage with a bold, darker edge.

The original Sonic Generations served as both a tribute to Sonic's fast-paced heritage and a pivotal point after the series’ mixed forays into 3D.

While celebrated for its callbacks and clever humor, its mechanical inconsistencies and uneven pacing left both veterans and newcomers wanting more. Fast forward to today and Sonic Team, alongside SEGA, endeavors to address these longstanding critiques through Sonic x Shadow Generations.

This expanded edition isn’t merely a remaster; it splits the experience in two, offering both the classic Sonic Generations campaign and an all-new Shadow Generations storyline as standalone options from the main menu.

Fans familiar with the Sonic universe will appreciate how Shadow's adventure is untethered from the conventions of the original campaign, featuring its own traversal abilities and a fresh “open-zone” structure inspired by Sonic Frontiers.

As players progress, new overworld mechanics unlock previously inaccessible secrets, significantly deepening replay value and enhancing the meta-gameplay first introduced over a decade ago. The moment-to-moment action remains true to the franchise's 3D roots: signature high-speed platforming, vibrant stages, and pulse-quickening setpieces abound.

Still, some minor control jitters and momentum issues—a trademark of the series’ 3D outings—persist, especially when making subtle adjustments with the analog controls.

Notably, Shadow’s campaign stands out for its kaleidoscopic visuals and fluid mid-stage transformations, offering fresh spectacle and intriguing gameplay changes that build upon visual effects debuted in Sonic Frontiers. Performance on the Nintendo Switch, however, proves to be a mixed bag.

The core Sonic Generations campaign maintains visual fidelity comparable to the Xbox 360 original but is occasionally marred by stuttery frame pacing.

Shadow’s new segment, relying on a more modern engine, often struggles to maintain a consistent 30 frames per second, particularly in docked mode.

A more pronounced drop in resolution in handheld mode can limit visibility and, in some cases, hinder gameplay—potentially impacting Switch Lite users most. Beyond technical performance, long-time fans may notice a notable shift in narrative tone.

Where the original Generations balanced celebratory nostalgia with self-aware humor, the updated script opts for a more serious, cohesive storyline.

While some might welcome the effort toward narrative depth, it occasionally comes at the expense of the franchise's hallmark lightness, drawing comparisons to the melodramatic style of Sonic the Hedgehog (2006). Despite these shortcomings, Sonic x Shadow Generations earns a partial recommendation thanks to its expanded scope, creative level design, and the distinct flavor that Shadow brings to the experience.

The dual campaigns nearly double the original’s content, delivering plenty of value for series fans eager to revisit—and expand upon—a pivotal chapter in Sonic history. Sonic x Shadow Generations for Nintendo Switch is available via eShop and physical retailers beginning October 25, 2024.

Review copy provided by SEGA.

Nintendo Switch Nintendo Shadow Generations Sonic Team SEGA Switch Sonic x Shadow Generations Shadow Sonic