Sonic x Shadow Generations Switch 2 Edition Review: Performance Boosts but No Upgrade Path

Sonic x Shadow Generations made its debut alongside the highly anticipated Nintendo Switch 2, joining launch titles like Mario Kart World and Nintendo Switch 2 Welcome Tour.

Developed by SEGA, this title brought together classic Sonic speed and Shadow’s signature gameplay, delivering a blend of nostalgia and new experiences.

While the original Nintendo Switch version released in late 2023 garnered positive feedback for its gameplay, performance concerns held it back from being a truly standout title. With the Nintendo Switch 2 Edition of Sonic x Shadow Generations, SEGA aims to address the technical shortcomings of the previous release.

Notably, the Switch 2 Edition does not offer any additional content; instead, its main selling point is a significant performance and graphics upgrade—an important distinction for returning players.

According to our updated review, the focus is squarely on the improvements in frame rate and resolution, two critical performance metrics for platformers of this caliber. One key point for returning players: if you already purchased Sonic x Shadow Generations for Nintendo Switch, there is no upgrade option or discount path available for upgrading to the Switch 2 Edition.

Players must repurchase the game at full retail price on the Nintendo Switch 2 platform, a move that has stirred frustration within the community.

Despite this, the Switch 2 Edition does support save data transfers from the original version, allowing players to continue their progress on the new hardware.

However, the lack of a free or reduced-price upgrade remains the most contentious aspect of this re-release. On the technical front, Sonic Generations now offers a noticeably smoother experience.

The Nintendo Switch version previously targeted 30 frames per second, often meeting this target in gameplay but not always during intensive scenes.

The Switch 2 Edition boosts gameplay segments to 60 frames per second, providing fluid animation both in handheld and docked modes.

Some scenes, such as cutscenes and the title screen, continue to run at 30 frames per second in handheld mode, but overall, the improvement is substantial. Shadow Generations, which struggled the most on the original hardware due to poor resolution and inconsistent frame rates, is now significantly more stable.

The Switch 2 Edition introduces two selectable modes: Quality Mode and Performance Mode.

Quality Mode increases the resolution to 1080p at a steady 30 frames per second, while Performance Mode drops the resolution back to 720p but enables 60 frames per second gameplay.

For players who prefer handheld play, Performance Mode provides an optimal balance of smooth frame rate and responsive controls.

Those using a TV with frame interpolation may find Quality Mode preferable for its higher resolution. Despite these technical strides, the Switch 2 Edition of Sonic x Shadow Generations remains a tough sell for existing owners.

Without any new content or meaningful enhancements beyond graphics and performance, a full-price repurchase is difficult to justify.

However, for new players or those who missed the original release, this version currently stands as the best way to experience Sonic x Shadow Generations on Nintendo hardware. While the upgraded experience is welcome, prospective buyers who already own the original should be aware that improvements are limited to technical polish.

For those keen to jump in for the first time, monitoring potential discounts on the Nintendo Switch eShop in the coming months may offer a more attractive entry point.

In summary, while Sonic x Shadow Generations for Switch 2 raises the technical bar for SEGA’s platformer, its lack of an upgrade pathway is its most significant stumbling block.

Nintendo Switch 2 Nintendo Switch Nintendo Shadow Generations Switch 2 Switch Sonic x Shadow Generations Shadow Sonic Switch 2 Edition